The sizing and width of EN shoes is very inconsistent–the Iggdrasils are the only pair that worked for me because they’re fairly narrow and have a high arch.

I love the Keen Calistoga even though I can fit 1.5 feet in each shoe. I recently bought a second pair in Orion blue and ordered my usual size rather than size up and they fit perfectly. I’d say sticking with Keen is always a good idea for people with bunions. The Sienna mary jane is also very stretchy and comfortable. I have yet to try the Wear Around MJ, but it looks comfortable. Merrell and Teva make sporty mary janes, too, and I’ve found them to have a lot of room in the toe box.

If you live in a colder climate, I can also recommend EMU Australia boots (if you’re not dead set against the “Ugg” look). I have yet to compare them to other brands, but they are super comfortable, very roomy and soft, and I haven’t taken them off my feet since I opened them Christmas morning. They actually have arch support, too, and I’ve been able to stand all day on my feet at work and come home with no foot pain. I didn’t want to look trendy, so I hesitated for 2 years before buying them, but I highly recommend them.

Sorry the Iggdrasils didn’t work out. Keen never seems to disappoint. Hope this helped a little.